Difference Between Gooch Crucible and Sintered Glass Crucible

The key difference between Gooch crucible and sintered glass crucible is that Gooch crucibles can withstand very high temperatures than sintered glass crucibles.

Gooch crucible and sintered glass crucible are filtration devices we can use in laboratories for analytical processes. Gooch crucible is a type of filtration devices that can withstand very high temperatures. Sintered glass crucible is a type of filtration device made of Pyrex glass.

CONTENTS

1. Overview and Key Difference
2. What is Gooch Crucible 
3. What is Sintered Glass Crucible
4. Side by Side Comparison – Gooch Crucible vs Sintered Glass Crucible in Tabular Form
5. Summary

What is Gooch Crucible?

Gooch crucible is a type of filtration device we can use in laboratories. This instrument was named after Frank Austin Gooch. We can name it a Gooch filter as well. Gooch crucible is useful for collecting a precipitate directly within the vessel in which we can let the precipitate dry, make its ash and measure the weight of the analyte sample through gravimetric analysis.

Originally, this device was made as a standard platinum crucible in laboratories, and it contained a perforated base. This perforated base is important in placing the asbestos pulp from the filter mat. Thereafter, the crucible was heated in an oven in order to let the pulp dry until it obtained a constant weight that we can measure. This crucible can be subject to a high temperature for drying the filtrate, and we can also oxidize the content in the crucible or make the filtrate become its ash which has minimum weight. However, the use of platinum is expensive; thus, the material of the Gooch crucible was replaced with porcelain in 1882.

In some crucibles, there are asbestos double layers that separate them from a perforated porcelain plate. Additionally, some Gooch crucibles contain inorganic fibres such as glass in the place of asbestos. Gooch crucibles made of borosilicate glass and fritted glass bases are also common nowadays. Platinum Gooch crucibles also help in important applications like handling corrosive materials. In such applications, we cannot use porcelain. However, a Gooch crucible made of porcelain is enough for ashing a material at high temperature, and the crucibles made of borosilicate are enough for drying a material.

What is Sintered Glass Crucible

Sintered glass crucible is a type of filtration device made of Pyrex glass. Pyrex glass is an excellent resistant glass type. It is fitted with sintered ground glass, filter disc at a small distance above the lower end. Generally, this device is useful in directly collecting a precipitate that requires drying.

Moreover, these glass crucibles contain various degrees of porosity in order to suit precipitates of different sizes. There are two major types as G3 and G4; G3 is useful for most precipitates, whereas G4 is important in filtering few precipitate types. These crucible types cannot withstand temperatures above 400 Celsius degrees.

Furthermore, we cannot use a sintered glass crucible directly on a flame. Therefore, the precipitate in the sintered glass crucible is dried at temperatures ranging from 110 to 120 Celsius degrees inside an electric oven.

What is the Difference Between Gooch Crucible and Sintered Glass Crucible?

Gooch crucible and sintered glass crucible are filtration devices that we can use in laboratories for analytical processes. Gooch crucible is made of porcelain, whereas sintered glass crucible is made of Pyrex glass. The key difference between Gooch crucible and sintered glass crucible is that Gooch crucibles can withstand very high temperatures while sintered glass crucibles cannot withstand temperatures above 400 Celsius degrees.

The below infographic shows the differences between Gooch crucible and sintered glass crucible in tabular form.

Summary – Gooch Crucible vs Sintered Glass Crucible

Gooch crucible is a type of filtration device that we can use in laboratories. Sintered glass crucible is a type of filtration device made of Pyrex glass. The key difference between Gooch crucible and sintered glass crucible is that the Gooch crucibles can withstand very high temperatures while sintered glass crucibles cannot withstand temperatures above 400 Celsius degrees.

Reference:

1. “Sintered Glass Crucible.” Scribd, Available here.

Image Courtesy:

1. “Gooch-crucible” By Alex Charles Cumming and Sydney Alexander Kay – Page 113 of A Text-book of Quantitative Chemical Analysis (Public Domain) via Commons Wikimedia

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7pbXFn5yrnZ6YsqOx07CcnqZemLyue8OinZ%2Bdopq7pLGMm5ytr5Wau26zzqiaoWWTp8KktcGlnGaZnpl6tLXNrZyrnZRitK2t0qxknKqlmLajuMRo